While the NFL has made significant efforts to prioritize player safety by banning helmet-first hits to prevent concussions, it appears that a new form of dangerous tackling has emerged. The low hit by defenders has become the new high hit, leading to devastating knee injuries.
A recent example of this trend occurred during the Detroit Lions-Los Angeles Rams Wild Card playoff game over the weekend. Safety Kerby Joseph delivered a low hit to Rams tight end Tyler Higbee, resulting in Higbee tearing his ACL and MCL. This incident was eerily similar to an earlier hit by Joseph on Minnesota Vikings tight end T.J. Hockenson, which also resulted in ligament tears.
The hit on Higbee sparked controversy and drew criticism from fans and players alike. Rams quarterback Matthew Stafford, who was mic’d up during the game, expressed his frustration to Joseph, calling him out for the hit. However, Joseph defended his actions, stating that he aimed for the thigh board and avoided targeting the head.
Lions head coach Dan Campbell also came to Joseph’s defense, asserting that their team’s style of play prioritizes hitting with the shoulder and avoiding head contact. Campbell argued that the hit was not dirty but rather a result of their aggressive defensive strategy.
The NFL implemented a rule in 2018 prohibiting helmet-first hits and lowering the head during tackles. Players who violate this rule can face penalties ranging from 15-yard penalties to suspensions. Former Denver Broncos safety Kareem Jackson faced suspension and eventual release from the team for repeatedly leading with his head during tackles.
However, the implementation of this rule has not been without controversy. Some players argue that it can lead to more knee and lower body injuries since the head often comes before the shoulder in tackling movements. Former Seattle Seahawks cornerback Richard Sherman expressed concerns about the rule, stating that players naturally lead with their heads before their shoulders.
While the rule has successfully reduced concussions in the NFL, there is less research on ACL and knee injuries. The league’s Chief Medical Officer, Dr. Allen Sills, acknowledged the significance of knee ligament injuries in the 2019 injury report and stated that they are actively studying these injuries to better understand their causes and potential preventive measures.
In the case of Joseph’s hit on Higbee, no penalty was called, and the hit was deemed clean by the officials. Joseph has not faced any fines or penalties for the incident.
As the NFL continues to prioritize player safety, it is essential to find a balance between preventing concussions and minimizing other types of injuries. Further research and analysis will be necessary to determine the most effective measures to protect players from both head and knee injuries.